Bob Dylan
Live 1964: Concert At Philharmonic Hall, The Bootleg Series Volume 6
[Coumbia]
by K. Vicious
Trust Bob Dylan to be his customarily cryptic self of late, barking blues instead of singing tunes, making a self-serving movie called Masked And Anonymous and appearing in a Victoria’s Secret advertisement. Dylan fanatics out there are still waiting for a proper follow-up to 2001’s Love And Theft (one should note he churns out albums every four years these days), but the legendary songwriter is keeping everyone plenty busy by releasing his ‘rare’ or ‘unreleased’ material.
Through the years, Dylan has developed into a figure of mystique mainly because of the shroud of mystery over his infamous unreleased songs – a bunch of rejected numbers or some other mercurial performances. So if you are wondering why Bob Dylan’s legacy is now running out of secrets, then you could probably blame it all on Columbia Records’ ongoing, ‘official’ bootleg series. But it’s a good thing to get to hear these old stuff, right?
Live 1964 at Philharmonic Hall is number six in the (non-chronological) series and dates back to when Dylan was making his transition from a folk musician to embrace the hip quotient of electrified rock. For all purposes, this 1964 gig would have seem like a typical gathering of young, eager and adoring radicals expecting to hear his protest tunes. Joan Baez was still hanging around. But something new about Dylan’s songwriting was brewing, with or without his friends and fans knowing it, on that Halloween evening.
At that point, his rather whimsical new album Another Side Of Bob Dylan (1964) had only just been released – and his devoted fans already knew the songs pretty damned well – to signal his move towards freewheeling poetry. But Dylan even went a step further that night to preview material from his subsequent album of rock and roll shambles, Bringing It All Back Home (1964). How extraordinary an experience it must have been then for a fan to be there to witness Dylan finding his way around his new material, and to be standing there taking in the mindblowing lyrics (“The hollow horns plays wasted words/ Proves to warn that he not busy being born is busy dying”) of a song like his early incarnation here of the classic It’s Alright Ma, I’m Only Bleeding.
I mentioned rare stuff: well, this 2-CD collection includes live readings of the then-controversial Talkin’ John Birch Paranoid Blues (a leftist ‘protest song’, already appeared on volume 1), Silver Dagger (performed with Baez) and a randy version of If You Gotta Go, Go Now (also released on volume 1). Even better are his zippier performances of favorites like All I Really Wanna Do and I Don’t Believe You. It’s a shame that Dylan had to mar two of his best-written tunes, Don’t Think Twice It’s Alright and Mama You Been On My Mind, by hamming it up – perhaps he felt he needed by then to shy away from the intimate nature of the lyrics.
Or maybe he was just masquerading, as he joked during one of the interludes. This Philharmonic Hall concert reveals a side of Bob Dylan at his most inscrutable – sometimes earnest, sometimes playful, sometimes callous and cruel. But there is no mistaking his rebellious pose, and Dylan the performer at his electrifying best without yet immersing himself fully into rock and roll. In a few months from this concert, Dylan would harness the rebellion of his new creative voice onto Bringing It All Back Home, where his ties with the old-folkie crowd will be severed forever, and unapologetically, with the first clang of the electric guitar on Subterranean Homesick Blues. The rest, as they say, is mostly history.
|